Jump to content
Welsley

Real world mpg and range

Recommended Posts

17 hours ago, Monkeyfinger said:

With respect, a rather outdated view with regard to the capabilities of modern engines and the rest of the technologies built into the cars....in my opinion, anyway...

I have no doubt in the capabilities of modern turbo 4 bangers , but the fact remains that a larger engine is going to produce more torque allowing for more effortless power delivery. And if going for petrol due to low miles the added fuel costs of the 6cyl will be negligible. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, F10 530d said:

I have no doubt in the capabilities of modern turbo 4 bangers , but the fact remains that a larger engine is going to produce more torque allowing for more effortless power delivery. And if going for petrol due to low miles the added fuel costs of the 6cyl will be negligible. 

 

Very wrong. Mercedes AMG 45 CLA engine produce more power and the same torque (360hp and 450 Nm) compared to 540i (340 Hp and 450 Nm)  and faster than 540i (4.6 to 4.8s) . The exhaust note is far better as well.  Same could be said for 4 cylinder engines in Porsche and Audi RS cars

 

BMW is deliberately detuning their 4 cylinder engines in order to give markets for their 6 cylinder engines. 

 

Technology has moved on. Just buy what you like and enjoy 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, Babaikram said:

 

Very wrong. Mercedes AMG 45 CLA engine produce more power and the same torque (360hp and 450 Nm) compared to 540i (340 Hp and 450 Nm)  and faster than 540i (4.6 to 4.8s) . The exhaust note is far better as well.  Same could be said for 4 cylinder engines in Porsche and Audi RS cars

 

BMW is deliberately detuning their 4 cylinder engines in order to give markets for their 6 cylinder engines. 

 

Technology has moved on. Just buy what you like and enjoy 

 

Yep.. my last car was AMG A45...360bhp from 4cyl 2 litre turbo. Totally awesome, but I now drive a 530e. Go figure...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, Babaikram said:

 

Very wrong. Mercedes AMG 45 CLA engine produce more power and the same torque (360hp and 450 Nm) compared to 540i (340 Hp and 450 Nm)  and faster than 540i (4.6 to 4.8s) . The exhaust note is far better as well.  Same could be said for 4 cylinder engines in Porsche and Audi RS cars

 

BMW is deliberately detuning their 4 cylinder engines in order to give markets for their 6 cylinder engines. 

 

Technology has moved on. Just buy what you like and enjoy 

 

 

Everything is a compromise. You lose something with maxing out a 4 cylinder engine.  You also gain something like a blatting exhaust

 

Inline 6 cylinder engines are intrinsically smoother and torquey, becasue they are perfectly balanced. They will be used where that is important - bigger premium cars rather than sporty 

 

MB are also now developing a I6 engine for their S Class. It has a similar performance profile (slightly better becasue its a 48v hybrid) compared to the BMW I6.  Its a proper hybrid - the starter motor starts the engine, and charges the battery, and also boosts power output

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

G30 530e.
Just withdrawn from the dealer (2 months ago) the car marked 34 km of autonomy in pure electric.
Gradually now it has adapted to 25-26 km of autonomy in pure electric.
Can someone share their experience?
In dealership they say it is normal and depends on the driving style.
Now at the beginning I was struggling a lot now are a couple of weeks that I go in echo pro and max edrive with "an egg" under the accelerator, but does not change the autonomy. Are these predictive algorithms so long to learn a new driving style?

180518erange.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/15/2018 at 6:05 PM, Johnyboy said:

I'll give it a wash this weekend, but if there's not a significant improvement then you'll be hearing from my lawyers!

Picture after the event then please.:P

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/15/2018 at 4:26 PM, Back2Beemer said:

520d SE (17" wheels).

 

Currently covered 9k miles, and long term average is 48.9, however I'm frequently seeing 54mpg on a good run now the weather has improved / winter grade diesel has disappeared, so fully expect that to go up more.

 

Easily clearing 700+ miles to a tank.

 

Just driven to the Cotswolds and back over the past few days, with good weather and limited traffic. Fair few stretches of 50mph average speed checks, otherwise driven at 80mph (just being honest!).

 

Indicated 62.8 mpg and theoretical circa 900 mile range. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/15/2018 at 4:26 PM, Back2Beemer said:

520d SE (17" wheels).

 

Currently covered 9k miles, and long term average is 48.9, however I'm frequently seeing 54mpg on a good run now the weather has improved / winter grade diesel has disappeared, so fully expect that to go up more.

 

Easily clearing 700+ miles to a tank.

 

Just driven to the Cotswolds and back over the past few days, with good weather and limited traffic. Fair few stretches of 50mph average speed checks, otherwise driven at 80mph (just being honest!).

 

Indicated 62.8 mpg and theoretical circa 900 mile range. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, Babaikram said:

So people should buy whatever engines they want that suit their needs and pockets 

I think most people have, good sport to compare the MPG across the range and engine types - my 540 has now done enough miles (1200) for me to consider it run in, current MPG after a gentle few miles this week up to 32 it will drop considerably I'm sure once I start to ask it to perform as intended. :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a quick glance through here and ill make some points. 

 

My daily commute is 38 miles both ways, london traffic, M25, then else traffic. ready in the afternoon. I average 44mpg and get way over 650 miles per tank. 

 

Funnily enough, never been on a long run yet. Will be going Leicster next weekend so around 120 miles, hoping to see 55mpg on the motorway. 

 

Now, sub points, 4 cylinders are the future, like it or not. Porsche now doing 4 cylinders, and the A45 AMG is rightly so, the best example to show high performance from small displacement and cylinder count. 

 

We all know that high capacity engines are a dying breed. Next M140i will be a 2 litre 4 cylinder I know this for a Fact. It will produce circa 400bhp. I also heard that the same engine may be used in the next M3/M4.Yes a Straight 6 3.0d BMW is a joy to drive, but honestly, in todays day and age, a 2.0d is more than enough for 99% of the population - until they are banned all together that is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Carrera77 said:

 

Everything is a compromise. You lose something with maxing out a 4 cylinder engine.  You also gain something like a blatting exhaust

 

Inline 6 cylinder engines are intrinsically smoother and torquey, becasue they are perfectly balanced. They will be used where that is important - bigger premium cars rather than sporty 

 

MB are also now developing a I6 engine for their S Class. It has a similar performance profile (slightly better becasue its a 48v hybrid) compared to the BMW I6.  Its a proper hybrid - the starter motor starts the engine, and charges the battery, and also boosts power output

 

So what is the downside of torquey  and powerful 4 cylinder engines with good power delivery and sexy exhaust note. Look outside BMW. I was in Volvo S90 diesel. It was quiet inside and with almost no grunting engine sound outside and with a smooth power delivery. The world is moving on

Edited by Babaikram

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, saintalan said:

Hi guys I haven't been paying much attention to it but next tank I'll start to test it. Anything specific you want me to try on my 520i let me know.

My dad had a 520i back in 1985. 6 cylinders, 2litres. 130 bhp. Love the name... 520i

 

How you pleased with performance? As someone said, no one review on magazine whether the 530i is worth the difference. .. they all want to take the M5 back home instead. There are more reviews of M5 than potential buyers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Babaikram said:

So what is the downside of torquey  and powerful 4 cylinder engines with good power delivery and sexy exhaust note. Look outside BMW. I was in Volvo S90 diesel. It was quiet inside and with almost no grunting engine sound outside and with a smooth power delivery. The world is moving on

 

Not much and it will be very good in most cases. But the current I6 engines in the 5 series are the closest ICE analogue to all electric drive. 

There are lots of reasons why 4 cylinders are used - manufacturing , packaging , crash protection 

 

  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×